Feedback on Hibiscus leaves
Moderator: Mustafa
Feedback on Hibiscus leaves
Hi Folks, and Greetings from Australia.
This is my first post, so I hope I've researched enough - I've spent the last 5 hours searching and looking at previous posts and looking at articles so here's the Q;
Here in sunny Queensland, the occurrence of trees such as oak, chestnut and ash are pretty much limited to botanical gardens in major cities, lol. So I'm trying to be prepared and find a source for leaves to use in my shrimp tanks before I get too carried away.
I've considered local common species such as Eucalypt, and Maleluca, but am concerned about the high sap/aromatic content of the leaves. I'm happy to experiment in the future, but am not willing to risk the lives of my critters at this stage. I also considered Lilly Pilly leaves (Syzigium sp.), which may be a more likely candidate, but the leaves are generally quite small.
So what I was wondering about was if anybody would be kind enough to provide me with any feedback you have on the use of Hibiscus leaves. I know (after reading through older threads) that at lest a few of you have tried them, so I was wondering what species of shrimp you have tried them with, and whether you have noted differences to other types of leaves, what spp of Hibiscus you have used (common garden variety or otherwise), and anything else you think might be helpful, lol. If you have any other suggestions to what I might try locally, that would also be helpful. As an aside I can get cattappa leaves (I think that's the almond that betta breeder's use?) but I note that a lot of folks mentioned it acts too acidicly on the water.
*edit: forgot to mention; the reason I asked about Hibiscus leaves specifically, was that my father has about 20 bushes growing on his property, so they're pretty easily accessible Cheers.*
Consider me a sponge
Gratefully,
Rufus
This is my first post, so I hope I've researched enough - I've spent the last 5 hours searching and looking at previous posts and looking at articles so here's the Q;
Here in sunny Queensland, the occurrence of trees such as oak, chestnut and ash are pretty much limited to botanical gardens in major cities, lol. So I'm trying to be prepared and find a source for leaves to use in my shrimp tanks before I get too carried away.
I've considered local common species such as Eucalypt, and Maleluca, but am concerned about the high sap/aromatic content of the leaves. I'm happy to experiment in the future, but am not willing to risk the lives of my critters at this stage. I also considered Lilly Pilly leaves (Syzigium sp.), which may be a more likely candidate, but the leaves are generally quite small.
So what I was wondering about was if anybody would be kind enough to provide me with any feedback you have on the use of Hibiscus leaves. I know (after reading through older threads) that at lest a few of you have tried them, so I was wondering what species of shrimp you have tried them with, and whether you have noted differences to other types of leaves, what spp of Hibiscus you have used (common garden variety or otherwise), and anything else you think might be helpful, lol. If you have any other suggestions to what I might try locally, that would also be helpful. As an aside I can get cattappa leaves (I think that's the almond that betta breeder's use?) but I note that a lot of folks mentioned it acts too acidicly on the water.
*edit: forgot to mention; the reason I asked about Hibiscus leaves specifically, was that my father has about 20 bushes growing on his property, so they're pretty easily accessible Cheers.*
Consider me a sponge
Gratefully,
Rufus
- southerndesert
- Shrimpoholic
- Posts: 281
- Joined: Mon Sep 03, 2007 10:33 am
- Location: Arizona
- Contact:
- southerndesert
- Shrimpoholic
- Posts: 281
- Joined: Mon Sep 03, 2007 10:33 am
- Location: Arizona
- Contact:
I have been serious about shrimp for less than a year myself so my experience is limited to what has worked for me up until now... I use mostly Mulberry leaves as they are easy to get from one of the properties I manage and I know there were no sprays used on them.
I have used leaves since starting in all my tanks and have had much success so far with no major disasters, so having a couple leaves in the tank at least can't hurt.
This site and forum have been a BIG factor in this and my first shrimp only tanks were set up using Mustafa's advise at the articles section and the help of all here at the forum. Leaves were mentioned as beneficial so I have always used them.
Bill
I have used leaves since starting in all my tanks and have had much success so far with no major disasters, so having a couple leaves in the tank at least can't hurt.
This site and forum have been a BIG factor in this and my first shrimp only tanks were set up using Mustafa's advise at the articles section and the help of all here at the forum. Leaves were mentioned as beneficial so I have always used them.
Bill
Okay guys, thanks. I guess the main thing I was concerned about was I'd read the "just about" a number of times - it's that part of the equation I want to avoid and haven't really turned up any solid info on what sort of leaves I should actually steer clear of.
I was wandering around yesterday and realised I have a fair few macadamia and avocado leaves. They're just as easy to come by as the Hibiscus and are slightly heavier duty, so unless anyone could think of a reason not to, I reckon I'll give these a shot.
Thanks again
I was wandering around yesterday and realised I have a fair few macadamia and avocado leaves. They're just as easy to come by as the Hibiscus and are slightly heavier duty, so unless anyone could think of a reason not to, I reckon I'll give these a shot.
Thanks again
- Neonshrimp
- Master Shrimp Nut
- Posts: 2296
- Joined: Wed May 24, 2006 5:37 pm
- Location: California, USA